Reactive or Creative Leadership 

What pressure reveals about leadership patterns and purposeful action

A chief executive I once worked with had a habit he was not particularly proud of.

When the organisation was under pressure, he became extremely helpful.

He attended more meetings, checked more work and became involved in decisions several levels below him. From his perspective, he was supporting the team. From the team’s perspective, he was taking over.

Over time, people gradually stopped making decisions without him. Senior managers started checking what they thought he wanted before committing themselves, and the more dependent the organisation became, the more convinced he became that he needed to stay closely involved.

It was a perfect loop.

And, importantly, none of it was intentional.

Pressure tends to reveal our default settings

Most leaders can describe the kind of leader they want to be: calm, strategic, empowering, courageous, collaborative.

The more interesting question is what happens when they are tired, anxious or under pressure. That is often when our deeper leadership patterns become visible.

The Leadership Circle describes a distinction between Creative and Reactive leadership tendencies. The word “reactive” can sound pejorative, but that misses the point. Reactive patterns usually developed for a reason. At some stage they helped us succeed.

A leader who learned that being right brought approval may become highly analytical and demanding. Someone who learned to create harmony may become exceptionally good at reading the room, but reluctant to challenge others. Someone who built a career by being dependable may eventually struggle to delegate because their identity is tied to being the person who can always be relied upon.

The problem is not that these strengths are bad, it’s what happens when we become dependent on them.

The successful strategy that stops working

For the chief executive, competence had always been rewarded. Earlier in his career, being the person who could step in and solve problems had accelerated his progress.

But as his responsibility grew, the same behaviour began to have a different effect.

The organisation no longer needed him to solve more problems. It needed him to create an environment in which other people could solve them which required a shift from a question that had served him well for twenty years:

How can I make sure this goes well?

to a very different question:

What leadership does this situation need from me?

Those questions sound similar but they are not.

The first begins with anxiety and control. The second begins with purpose.

Creative leadership is not about being creative

The term “Creative leadership” is sometimes misunderstood. It does not mean brainstorming, innovation or being unconventional. It refers to leadership organised around a sense of purpose rather than around the protection of self.

A Reactive response might be, “I need to prove I know what I’m doing,” whereas a more Creative response might be, “What outcome are we trying to create?”

Reactive might sound like, “I need everyone to be comfortable with this decision.” Creative asks, “What conversation are we avoiding because it matters?”

Reactive says, “I need to keep control.” Creative asks, “What capability does this team need to build?”

The behaviour may look subtle from the outside, but internally the difference is significant.

Catching yourself in the act

The chief executive began experimenting with something simple. Whenever he felt the urge to intervene in a problem owned by one of his executives, he paused and asked:

Am I about to add value, or relieve my own anxiety?

It became an unexpectedly powerful question.

Sometimes he did need to intervene. At other times, he realised that what he really wanted was reassurance.

Instead of taking over, he began asking:

“What are you thinking?”

“What options have you considered?”

“What do you need from me?”

“What decision do you think we should make?”

At first, this felt slower. Then something interesting happened.

His team became stronger.

Executives came to meetings with clearer recommendations. People were more willing to make decisions. The chief executive found himself spending less time in operational detail and more time thinking about the organisation’s future.

The business had not changed because he learned a new leadership technique. It changed because he changed the internal place from which he was leading.

The question beneath the behaviour

Much leadership development focuses on what leaders should do: listen more, delegate, give feedback, communicate clearly.

All useful, but behaviour is often downstream from something deeper.

If I believe my value depends on being the smartest person in the room, “listen more” will only take me so far. If I believe conflict threatens relationships, a course on courageous conversations will not automatically make me courageous. If my sense of security comes from control, delegation will always feel risky.

The deeper developmental question is:

What is driving the behaviour?

Once a leader can see that, choice becomes possible.

Pressure will always produce reactions. The aim is not to eliminate them. It is to notice them early enough that they do not end up running the organisation.

Previous
Previous

Technical Problems vs Adaptive Challenges

Next
Next

The Stories Leaders Tell Themselves