Why smart leaders get stuck solving human challenges with technical fixes
A senior leadership team had a problem.
Staff engagement scores had fallen for the second year in a row. Turnover was increasing, exit interviews were becoming more candid, and the themes were familiar: communication, workload, a lack of confidence in senior management.
The response was immediate. A working group was established, the employee survey was analysed in more detail, communication protocols were reviewed, a new intranet was commissioned, and managers were given templates for team meetings. The organisation also introduced a quarterly staff forum so that senior leaders could communicate more directly with employees.
Six months later, another pulse survey was run.
Almost nothing had changed.
The frustrating part was that the leadership team had done many of the things competent leaders are trained to do. They had gathered data, assigned responsibility, created a plan and implemented a series of solutions. The problem was not a lack of effort or capability.
The difficulty was that they had treated an adaptive challenge as though it were a technical problem.
When expertise really does solve the problem
Ronald Heifetz and his colleagues at Harvard made a useful distinction between technical problems and adaptive challenges. Technical problems can be difficult and may require significant expertise, money or coordination, but broadly speaking, the problem is understood and somebody knows how to solve it.
If a payroll system fails, you call the people who understand payroll systems. If a building has a structural defect, you engage an engineer. If a business has inconsistent reporting, you can redesign the reporting process.
These problems may be complicated, but they are still capable of being solved primarily through expertise and authority.
Adaptive challenges are different. They arise when progress requires people to change something about themselves: their assumptions, loyalties, habits, relationships, priorities or ways of working. There is no expert standing outside the system with the answer, because the people inside the system have to do much of the learning themselves.
And that was what was happening with this leadership team.
The problem was not primarily that employees lacked information. People did not trust what they were hearing.
That is a very different problem.
The temptation to reach for the hammer
Leaders are often promoted because they are good at solving problems. Something goes wrong, they diagnose it, decide what needs to happen and mobilise resources. That capability is enormously valuable but it can also become a trap.
When our main tool is expertise, we tend to frame problems in ways that allow expertise to solve them. We introduce a process, restructure, change the meeting cadence, commission a review, send people to training.
Sometimes those are exactly the right interventions.
But sometimes they are a way of avoiding the more difficult question:
What would have to change in us for this situation to improve?
For the leadership team dealing with falling engagement, that question led somewhere much less comfortable. They discovered that managers often felt decisions were presented as “consultation” after the decisions had effectively been made. Senior leaders believed they were being open; employees experienced them as defensive when challenged. Teams had learned that difficult news travelled upwards slowly, while positive news travelled quickly.
None of these issues could be fixed by improving the intranet.
The work changes when the diagnosis changes
Once the team recognised the adaptive nature of the problem, the work became different.
Instead of asking, “How do we communicate more effectively?”, they began asking, “Why don’t people believe they can speak openly with us?”
Instead of asking, “How do we improve engagement scores?”, they asked, “What do people experience when they disagree with someone more senior?”
And instead of asking, “What initiative should we introduce?”, they asked, “What are we doing that may be contributing to the problem?”
Those questions do not produce an immediate action plan which can feel deeply uncomfortable for leaders accustomed to moving quickly, but adaptive work often begins with resisting the urge to act long enough to understand what is really happening.
The leadership team began holding smaller conversations with employees. Leaders practised listening without explaining or defending. They paid attention to where their own behaviour contradicted the culture they said they wanted.
Some of the changes were surprisingly small. One leader learned to say, “Tell me more,” and “Help me understand where you’re coming from,” rather than immediately explaining why a decision had been made. Another began deliberately inviting the most sceptical person in the room to speak first. The executive team started identifying decisions that were genuinely open to influence, rather than calling everything consultation.
Gradually, people began taking more interpersonal risks and it wasn’t because a new communication strategy had been launched, but because their experience of leadership had begun to change.
A useful question for leaders
When an issue persists despite repeated efforts to solve it, it is worth asking:
Are we dealing with a problem that needs a better answer, or a challenge that requires new learning?
If expertise, authority and process can solve it, use them. But if the issue involves trust, culture, collaboration, accountability, behaviour, identity or competing values, there is a good chance that at least part of the challenge is adaptive.
Adaptive challenges cannot simply be fixed by the people at the top. They have to be worked through by the people who are part of them, which is slower, but it’s also where some of the most important leadership work begins.